The only question left is: Who on the forum wants to propose arguments for which 5-wheel rotation pattern is best? And why? I have to decide soon since I can't change the order until the second set of tires. And I've got only 10 to 18 months to make this decision .??If you rotate in the spare you get 20% more life out of the set. Rotating that spare makes a rotation simple easy because you only need one good jack and only one corner is off the ground at a time. You can do the whole swap in 10 minutes. If you need to use the spare it will already be worn close enough to match the diameter of the others. If you don’t rotate in the spare because you think you are saving from having to buy a 5th, you will have to get the same size and type of tire next time. Can’t decide to go bigger unless you buy a 5th anyway.