Curious Why it Seems so Many People Want a Manual Trans?

[Hkak45]

Manual trans are better in snowy conditions too since complete control over gear and rpm. And I don't drive anywhere with traffic so I have fun shifting gears since all country roads. YMMV

Sponsored

 

[71to21-2DR]

I am curious if these new 10 speed autos are able to be manually held in each lower gear 1,2,3?

 

[Mr. Nice]

Because any car with a manual transmission is more fun and engaging than it’s automatic version. Its as simple as that.

You couldn’t be more correct. Especially in these circumstances:

Heavy stop and go traffic
Parking lots
Driving in snow and ice
Operating any controls
Needing to drive with one hand
Steering and shifting at same time is great fun
Starting on steep grades
Drag racing
Drinking/eating
Cruise control?
Road racing
Emergency situations

I’m sure there’s a few more…

 

[71to21-2DR]

You couldn’t be more correct. Especially in these circumstances:

Heavy stop and go traffic
Parking lots
Driving in snow and ice
Operating any controls
Needing to drive with one hand
Steering and shifting at same time is great fun
Starting on steep grades
Drag racing
Drinking/eating
Cruise control?
Road racing
Emergency situations

I’m sure there’s a few more…

I’m sure he’s talking about rowing through the gears and winding it up and having fun!

 

[BigFootie]

You couldn’t be more correct. Especially in these circumstances:

Heavy stop and go traffic
Parking lots
Driving in snow and ice
Operating any controls
Needing to drive with one hand
Steering and shifting at same time is great fun
Starting on steep grades
Drag racing
Drinking/eating
Cruise control?
Road racing
Emergency situations

I’m sure there’s a few more…

Really? Ok. I’m pretty sure I’ve done all of those and a few more with a manual transmission.

 

[gaspasm]

Manuals are just fun!! It’s you and the vehicle.
“Mind meld”. Just feels awesome. Plus not many people can steal it - even with the keys in it.

 

[BroncoAZ]

A modern automatic is better in most situations than a stick, but I want to control all aspects of my vehicle so I but manuals. Rock crawling with a stick is certainly more challenging, but I enjoy it. The fact that not everyone can drive one is just icing on the cake.

 

[Virtual-Chris]

You mean paddle shifted automatic

No, I mean a paddle shifted manual such as I had in my BMW M5 (SMG)…

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_manual_transmission

This is the ideal tranny for a performance car (IMHO).

 

[mjohnso3]

I learned to drive on one of these, my first vehicle was a 69 Bronco, I think I was tramautize by the 3 on the tree and tried to stick with automatic ever since.

 

[kodiakisland]

Driven quite a few 3 on the trees. Loved every one.

You’re either a manual person, or you are not. Those of us who are can’t explain in terms an auto person would understand. It’s in our blood and it’s who we are. I always want a manual, and yes, I’ve driven one everywhere and done everything over the last 38 years or so of driving one.

If you don’t want a manual, don’t get one.

 

[Amcap76]

My default snarky answer to this is “If you have to ask, you wouldn’t understand”. It’s just a preference. Some love to drive a vehicle while others are content to ride in one.

 

[Amcap76]

I learned to drive on one of these, my first vehicle was a 69 Bronco, I think I was tramautize by the 3 on the tree and tried to stick with automatic ever since.

I miss having a column shift. I’m always looking for a good one to teach my kids on.
Also, it’s the ultimate anti-theft set up these days.

 

[grayshadow]

Manual shift keeps me from texting and driving.

 

[Moya7]

Curious why a manual is so important. I know, some people like stick shift trans, but why in a Bronco? Do you get a stick in all of your other cars and trucks? Not trying to start a stick vs auto debate (but a good discussion is fine), but I've seen so many comments about a manual I'm wonder what folks reasoning is.

Part of my question is that for almost ever there has been a perception that a manual is better off road. However, this perception is almost entirely folks who have little off road experience. Experience shows that an auto has many advantages over a stick off road. So, what the heck, why do so many folks want a stick Bronco?

I love manuals but I ordered an auto. My BMW has manual shift as well as paddles. I love all the options I have for driving so it works out great for me. I do drive my sons e30 manual sometimes and I love it, but not in bad traffic, just local driving. All that being said, its personal preference, plain and simple. Plus there's the fact that manuals are not easy to come by anymore and I get it. And if I could buy my 1980 911sc tractor back I would in a heartbeat.

 

[gaspasm]

Extra plus. Teaching kids to drive a manual makes them focus on driving and not the phone

Sponsored