Up or down, the amount of shit that's going to fall down between those seats is going to be comical.2DR has always been 4 seats. Probably because of where the seats are located relative to the wheel wells. I never noticed the gap between the seats either. OP has another thread with videos of Badlands 2DR and 4DR and the gap is present on that 2DR as well.
EDIT: Are there any Oxford Whites there? That is the one color I have not seen a lot of.