Mine rattles a lot when the top is all the way up. I have heard when the top is down, the rubber bounce pad isnt up high enough. Sounds like what you may be experiencing. Check out this video for a solution:
I am sure this has been discussed before, but I am trying to find out if I am just overly sensitive to the noise or if there is an issue with my soft top.
It seems like every time I drive my Bronco, the soft top develops some new squeak or creak or rattle. Mainly from the rear/passenger side...