There are pics of the Weathertech on page 2 of this thread. Comparing to your pictures it looks like the Weathertech has better coverage up the sides and forward on the front mats.I couldn’t take it anymore. Saying one of the three mat types is better than the other is a total opinion. The ford mats aren’t “thin or cheap” feeling. They hold more than enough slush and mud too. I’ve included pictures for comparison since no one else has.
Now if someone could post pictures of the different Husky liners.