Why do we hate Auto Start/Stop so much?

[CarmeloS]

Since you've decided to make it into a political/philosophical thing with your elementary "analogy" instead of just the topic at hand...I pose a question to you....

What happens if I am wrong? You've allowed your engine to shut down, you've reduced your footprint a little bit and you have made the world a better place.

What happens if YOU are wrong? Our grandkids have nowhere to live.

I'll take choice A and do my best to make sure MY grandkids AND your's have a planet to live on.

You also are aware Volcanos erupting emit a ton of CO2 back into the atmosphere right, thus negating “the savings” ass provides

Been talking about ice caps melting and stuff since I was a kid, no one talks about the hole in the Ozone layer since the 90s and what about acid rain.
Nothings happening, they’re just trying to scare the gullible sheep and children so they can tax us more and seize even more control over our lives.

Sponsored

 

[Anvilair1973]

it's just not that likely a caterpillar D11 is idling at an intersection waiting for the red light to shift.

that's what the semi-trailer is for!

Nope, they just idle on the job site... a lot. But like I said R&D scrapped the idea due to wear issues.

 

[Lcubed]

Nope, they just idle on the job site... a lot. But like I said R&D scrapped the idea due to wear issues.

that's why hybrid electric was introduced.

just totally shut down the motor for extended amounts of time.

caterpillar decided it was easier to do that than electrify the necessary parts of the lubrication system to support lots of momentary on/off

 

[Jeffp1108]

You also are aware Volcanos erupting emit a ton of CO2 back into the atmosphere right, thus negating “the savings” ass provides

Been talking about ice caps melting and stuff since I was a kid, no one talks about the hole in the Ozone layer since the 90s and what about acid rain.
Nothings happening, they’re just trying to scare the gullible sheep and children so they can tax us more and seize even more control over our lives.

Since you didn't answer my question, I'll assume that you haven't got a logical answer. Take care out there. Not going to take up this thread with an asinine argument.

 

[CarmeloS]

Since you didn't answer my question, I'll assume that you haven't got a logical answer. Take care out there. Not going to take up this thread with an asinine argument.

Let's see, whatcha ask again...

"Since you've decided to make it into a political/philosophical thing with your elementary "analogy" instead of just the topic at hand...I pose a question to you....

What happens if I am wrong? You've allowed your engine to shut down, you've reduced your footprint a little bit and you have made the world a better place.
If? You are wrong. Before I was even a thought in my teenage parents minds, they were going through the lies of global cooling in the 1970s. That became acid rain, ozone layer, global warming, and now just "Climate Change", because a heatwave in Summer or a blizzard in winter suffices as "Climate change"
What happens if YOU are wrong? Our grandkids have nowhere to live.
Really? I doubt it. Humans are resourceful, enough post apocalyptic films prove that. Also, wasn't the world supposed to end by now
I'll take choice A and do my best to make sure MY grandkids AND your's have a planet to live on."

Again, Volcanos erupting spew a shit ton of CO2 into the atmosphere, and I'm not eating Ze Bugs or giving up my cars "to save the planet"

 

[Cav427]

Since you've decided to make it into a political/philosophical thing with your elementary "analogy" instead of just the topic at hand...I pose a question to you....

What happens if I am wrong? You've allowed your engine to shut down, you've reduced your footprint a little bit and you have made the world a better place.

What happens if YOU are wrong? Our grandkids have nowhere to live.

I'll take choice A and do my best to make sure MY grandkids AND your's have a planet to live on.

If one is that concerned about their carbon footprint perhaps they should not have purchased a Bronco, or fly, or even worse own their own jet...

We do have carbon dioxide scrubbers that are very efficient and produce a marvelous substance called wood. These scrubbers are called trees, however there are those that would like to cut them down to install giant pinwheels that kill birds that eat insects, or solar panels that absorb infrared and create more heat. 4/1000's of a percent of CO2 or 5/1000's of a percent is not going to put a dent in temperatures. 2 to 3/1000's of a percent and plants have trouble performing photosynthesis. CO2 is the gas of life, without it plants and life on earth are not possible. The biggest driver of global temperatures is that big bright yellow orb in the sky that produces about 1,350 Watts per square meter at it's peak.

Believe what you want, but the uncomfortable truth is simple, there are those that want to take more and limit freedom of movement.

Want to prevent global warming, and do your part? Remove the top and turn the air on high, enjoy the sun and take your kids for a ride.

Auto start stop is like wearing a speedo in a snow storm.

 

[CarmeloS]

If one is that concerned about their carbon footprint perhaps they should not have purchased a Bronco, or fly, or even worse own their own jet...
Exactly. I'll take it seriously when most of these profits of doom give up their mega mansions (plural, not singular), jets, cars and take public transportation
We do have carbon dioxide scrubbers that are very efficient and produce a marvelous substance called wood. These scrubbers are called trees, however there are those that would like to cut them down to install giant pinwheels that kill birds that eat insects, or solar panels that absorb infrared and create more heat. 4/1000's of a percent of CO2 or 5/1000's of a percent is not going to put a dent in temperatures. 2 to 3/1000's of a percent and plants have trouble performing photosynthesis. CO2 is the gas of life, without it plants and life on earth are not possible. The biggest driver of global temperatures is that big bright yellow orb in the sky that produces about 1,350 Watts per square meter at it's peak.
Don't forget the Windmills have to be buried, and create Ultra-sound that messes us up. Heard a story ages ago about a couple on a farm near a windmill, their dog died suddenly and the vet confirmed the organs shrunk. Solar panels also have toxic chemicals and modern windmills use oil
Believe what you want, but the uncomfortable truth is simple, there are those that want to take more and limit freedom of movement.
See my first reply to that. Like I'm letting anyone take away my God Given Rights here
Want to prevent global warming, and do your part? Remove the top and turn the air on high, enjoy the sun and take your kids for a ride.
I do my part during the summer
Auto start stop is like wearing a speedo in a snow storm.
I got a few NSFW choice words, but this works

You really wanna be green and efficient? Get a pre-2000s car that weighed nothing and could achieve 40-50mpg without cvt's and hybrid technology, daily that and actually make a difference.

Thinking you're making a difference because the car stalls out by design at the light and eats up reaction time when it restarts is just asinine

 

[BigMeatsBronco]

stolen from a many years old f150forum.com post:


While this was true of turbo's of the past, it is not true for the EB. The EB uses liquid/oil cooled turbos that do not require a turbo timer or idle for 30 seconds to get the turbo's cooled down. If you want more information on this subject the try this Garrett website on liquid cooled turbos.

======================
it's not that hard to imagine the same oil that circulates for the turbo's after engine shutdown might be also be used in a similar fashion during ASS

it's not like FORD hasn't seen this solution in the past ...

liquid cooled turbos are NOT new, it's just an excuse to promote the eco name.

 

[BigMeatsBronco]

Since you didn't answer my question, I'll assume that you haven't got a logical answer. Take care out there. Not going to take up this thread with an asinine argument.

too bad you don't realize the truthi also asked service manager at my porsche dealer about ASS, I specifically asked if the starters have been updated or made more reliable and if the ring gear in the transmission was submerged in oil. His answer was nope they haven't made any changes to any of it and all they do is replace a whole lot more starters on Porsches now. I suggest you call a few mechanics and service centers and find out this information for yourself and then maybe you'll be a believer

 

[mig1980]

It greatly diminishes the life of your engine.

I've thought about this. Would it be accurate to say that it, in fact, reduces the life of your engine (e.g., starter, spark plugs, etc.) or has Ford and others designed these engines to sustain longevity.

I think about the Toyota Prius or any other hybrid. It basically does the same thing. We have owner a Prius for over a decade and it has been rock solid.

Thoughts??

 

[Lcubed]

liquid cooled turbos are NOT new, it's just an excuse to promote the eco name.

The point was it was no longer required to idle and cool down the turbos since this is mitigated in the system design.

 

[CarmeloS]

The point was it was no longer required to idle and cool down the turbos since this is mitigated in the system design.

I knew whathca meant. It's no longer the 80s and 90s, and even if you drive hard, unless you're tracking it, no need for a daily driver

I forget when they basically were no longer needed for dailies

 

[timhood]

Here’s the ultimate word on Auto Stop/Start: if you hate it, pay for a defeat device and consider that money well spent. You got a beefed-up starter that will never die out of the deal, so it should still be a win in your mind.

P.S. For those wondering why it doesn’t default to off or why it doesn’t stay off after you turn off the engine, it’s because Ford can’t claim the increase in fuel economy toward their CAFE requirements unless it defaults to on as delivered.

 

[Porque No]

I dislike it because when it’s 100 degrees out, I don’t want my AC blowing less than super cold air when the engine turns off

 

[CarmeloS]

I dislike it because when it’s 100 degrees out, I don’t want my AC blowing less than super cold air when the engine turns off

And you're in Texas no less, so you really don't wanna that AC to go out.

Never been to San Antonio btw, whats the part of Texas like? Dallas and Brownsville are where I've been

Sponsored